i’m just sayin’

i’m just sayin’

Gary Carpenter  //  This is my online hub. It feeds my Facebook wall, my twitter stream, and my Blog. It will probably get a bit noisy but we will see. I have a wonderful wife, three amazing daughters, great friends, family & church.....life is good! I'm no theologian or expert on anything, I just enjoy sharing things I find interesting, and sharing viewpoints and convictions that come from a love of research. I believe that the Bible is often much easier to understand than we like to think it is..

Oct 15 / 10:25am

Twitter bans repeating Tweets, but doesn't give definitions or guidelines.

I would think that in a time when Facebook has purchased Friendfeed and is adding all kinds of Twitter-like features, Yahoo introducing Meme (it's own micro-blogging platform) and the many other social networking options out there, that Twitter would not want to chase anyone but the most egregious spammers away.

Instead, they announce that they will ban repeat Tweeting. This will hurt many of their core users, and the users who bring the most value to the service: bloggers. Many bloggers have figured out that if they tweet out a new blog post once, only a few followers will see it, but if they tweet it three to four times, about four hours apart, they stand a pretty good chance of getting thier announcement into thier followers view. It also would likely get people who tweet for charitable causes banned.

I can see this having a huge unintended consequence. Spammers, the target of this policy, will just open a whole bunch of new accounts, and just Retweet each other. This is already a problem, but it will get much worse.

Again, with Facebook now owning Friendfeed, a twitter-like service that will most likely be integrated into Facebook at some point, I think it is dangerous to alienate a large portion of it's users. Read the articles below.

From Social Media Today:

Recurring Tweets On Twitter Accounts Are Being Discontinued
by Michael Gass on 10/13/2009 09:35

On Monday, October 12th, 2009, Twitter communicated that recurring tweets are in violation of their Terms of Service. Twitter’s rationale centered around the potential for recurring tweets to result in duplicate tweets.

From Twitter … Recurring Tweets are a violation no matter how they are done, including whether or not someone pays you to have a special privilege. We don’t want to see any duplicate tweets whatsoever- They pollute Twitter, and tools shouldn’t be given to enable people to break the rules. Spinnable text seems to just be a way to bypass the rules against duplicate updates and essentially provides the same problems.

For those of you using services such as Social Oomph (previously named Tweetlater), you can still schedule tweets for a specific day/time, just not recurring Tweets.


and I saw this via twitter last night:

I just read Social Media Todays article and the developer group’s announcement of Twitter’s intention to immediately ban any form of recurring tweets. I’m alarmed and concerned because I love Twitter. And with this move, they are taking a giant step toward killing their market and ceding it to Facebook.

Let’s look at the facts:

  • Twitter is going for the business market. They’ve already announced a plan for premium accounts and courted business through FAQs tailored to them.
  • Twitter’s whole technology is built around the idea of a continuous, real-time stream of information, from which TWEETS FALL OFF.
  • Bloggers, businesses, and anyone who actually wants to have a chance of being heard has to tweet the same message more than once. (Especially those who don’t have many thousands of followers.) If they don’t, the chances are miniscule of their tweet being seen by anyone, let alone large numbers of people. (See my last blog post, When is it spam?)
  • Although repeats are annoying for client users, the latest stats suggest that a majority of users access through the Web site, where tweets will not be seen unless recurring tweets are allowed.
  • Retweets aren’t enough, and recurring tweets help level the playing field. The larger your following, the better your chance of being retweeted. The combination of recurring tweets and hashtags gives tweeps with smaller followings a better chance of getting their message out, and building bigger followings.

It’s clear that many people use Twitter for social reasons. But a big part of the value on Twitter is its ability to surface new information. Twitter users are information junkies. Recurring tweets have a role to play in fulfilling that user goal.

1 comment

Oct 15, 2009
What are Twitter doing???

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter